First, classify the loss
The loss rate is the first guide to the treatment. A common field classification is:
| Loss type | Typical rate | Usual cause |
|---|---|---|
| Seepage | Under 10 bbl/hr | Permeable sands and high-permeability formations |
| Partial | 10 to 100 bbl/hr | Very permeable zones, small natural or induced fractures |
| Severe | Over 100 bbl/hr | Larger natural or induced fractures |
| Total | No returns | Large fractures, vugs or caverns |
Thresholds vary between operators, so follow your own loss-circulation guidelines.
Match particle size to the opening
Lost circulation material works by bridging the opening the mud is escaping through, then sealing it. A blend that is too fine passes straight through; one that is too coarse bridges at the face without sealing. For porous formations, a widely used rule of thumb (Abrams’ rule) is that the median particle size should be at least one third of the median pore-throat size. For fractures, the blend needs particles close to the fracture width, plus finer material to fill the gaps between them.
Particle shape matters too. Granular particles form the bridge, flakes lie across openings, and fibres knit the bridge into a mat and reduce its permeability. The most effective treatments usually combine all three.
Seepage losses: treat the active system
- Add fine to medium fibrous and granular LCM to the circulating system as a background treatment
- Check shaker screen sizes so the LCM is not removed at surface
- Good fluid loss control (for example with PAC) and a thin, tough filter cake help reduce seepage into permeable zones
Partial losses: a targeted pill
- Mix a pill of medium and coarse fibrous, granular and flaked LCM and spot it across the loss zone
- Reduce pump rate and equivalent circulating density while the pill works
- If losses continue, increase particle size and concentration in the next pill
Severe and total losses
- Pump high-concentration pills of coarse blends, often pulled above the zone and squeezed in stages
- If conventional LCM does not cure the loss, move to specialised plugs such as cross-linked polymer or cement plugs, following the operator’s procedures
Prevention: wellbore strengthening
Correctly sized LCM added before drilling into a known weak zone can help prop and seal small fractures as they form. This approach, known as wellbore strengthening, can reduce losses before they start.
Prove the blend in the lab
Two laboratory tests help choose the right blend before it goes downhole. The permeability plugging test (PPT) uses ceramic discs of known permeability to simulate porous formations. Slotted disc tests use metal discs with slots of set widths to simulate fractures. Both show whether a blend bridges and seals, and at what concentration.
Our R&D laboratory runs PPT and slotted disc tests, and we supply STFLUX™ fibrous, granular and flaked LCM for seepage to severe loss zones.
