Two ways to build viscosity
Viscosity in a water-based mud does two jobs: it lifts cuttings out of the hole, and it keeps them and the weighting material suspended when circulation stops. Bentonite and xanthan gum both build viscosity, but they do it in very different ways, and they suit different systems.
Bentonite: the clay base
Bentonite is a sodium montmorillonite clay. When it hydrates in fresh water, its thin platelets swell and link together, building viscosity and gel strength. It also helps form a filter cake, so it contributes to fluid loss control as well.
- Low cost, and the traditional base for spud muds and fresh-water systems
- Builds viscosity, gel strength and filter cake together
- Yields poorly in salt water: prehydrate it in fresh water first if it is going into a saline system
- Sensitive to contamination from calcium, salt and cement, which can flocculate it
- Adds solids to the mud, which raises plastic viscosity and can slow drilling
Xanthan gum: the biopolymer
Xanthan gum is a biopolymer produced by fermentation. It is strongly shear-thinning: thin at the high shear rates inside the drill pipe and bit, but thick at the low shear rates in the annulus and when the mud is static. That gives excellent low-shear-rate viscosity, which is what holds cuttings in suspension.
- Very effective for hole cleaning in deviated and horizontal wells
- Works in fresh water, seawater and brines
- Adds viscosity without adding clay solids, so it suits low-solids and clay-free systems
- Gives little fluid loss control on its own, so it is usually combined with PAC or starch
- Generally considered effective up to about 250°F (121°C), and can degrade through bacterial attack, so a biocide is often used
Side by side
| Bentonite | Xanthan gum | |
|---|---|---|
| Type | Clay (sodium montmorillonite) | Biopolymer |
| Best water | Fresh water | Fresh water, seawater and brines |
| Low-shear viscosity | Moderate | High |
| Fluid loss help | Yes, through filter cake | Little, combine with PAC |
| Adds solids | Yes | No |
| Main limits | Salt, calcium and cement contamination | Temperature and bacteria |
Which to choose
- Bentonite for fresh-water spud muds and top-hole sections, where cost matters and filter cake is welcome
- Xanthan gum for low-solids and clay-free polymer muds, salt-water systems, and deviated or horizontal wells that need strong hole cleaning
- Both together where a small amount of bentonite provides filter cake and xanthan gum provides low-shear viscosity
We supply API grade bentonite and xanthan gum, and our laboratory can test both in your mud to confirm the treatment before you order.
